New Roof or Roof Repair: A Comprehensive Guide on What to Choose

Your roof is central to your home because it stops water, animals, and wind from getting in, and it keeps you warm, safe, and dry. Humans need to have a place to live, and your roof, walls, and floors must be able to do this for you.  If you’ve been having leaks and damages, and are considering a new roof or a roof repair, read on!

To get your home safe and comfortable for you and your family, you need to look after your roof.

When you find something mysterious with your roof, you have a few ways to fix it. You can hire a roofing contractor to fix it for you most of the time so you can get a new roof look and get all the problems solved. Hiring a roofing contractor is often the cheapest way to improve your roof, especially if the damage isn’t too bad and your shingles aren’t too old.

Other times, the whole roof needs to be replaced. The best time to do this is when your shingles are nearing the end of their life expectancy or if you have a lot of damage.

Both ways, there is a lot to think about when you make this decision. You should go over your options very carefully so that you can make the best choice for your home.

Should I Repair or Replace my Existing Roof?


Because leaks can cause substantial damage in a short period, roofing problems are rarely something that can cause you trouble. As soon as you have a problem, the first step should be to determine the nature and devise a remedy. In most cases, this procedure entails contacting a roofing professional to inspect.

Repairing a roof rather than replacing it is usually the best option when the situation calls for it. A new roof costs more and it is expensive since replacing old shingles is generally far more costly than installing new ones.

When a repair only provides a temporary answer, opting for a replacement straight away can save you money over the long run.

Consider the following scenario: you require a minor repair that will cost approximately $400. If the restoration lasts for several years, it was a wise investment of time and money. However, if the repair only lasts six months and you need a new roof at that point, you’ve wasted $400 by not making a long-term investment in a better solution.

One of the reasons it’s a good idea to consult with a roofing specialist is to get an exact roof. The contractor will begin by inspecting the property and determining the best course of action. They will provide you with all of the information you need to make an informed decision.

Yes, moving forward with the repair will save you money in the short term. However, when you consider the long-term expenditures, including any damage that could do to your attic and home due to leaks, a replacement could save you money and time, and frustration.

Every circumstance is unique, so carefully consider your roofing alternatives to ensure that you select the most appropriate one for your property.

There are a variety of other roofing considerations.

4 Things to Consider Before Making a Decision

You should do the following things when deciding between a roof replacement and a roof repair.

1. Roofing System’s Age

Do you have any idea when to put your current roof in place? Depending on the type of roofing material used and warranty, the roof’s age may be a reliable indicator of when to replace it.

You should replace your roof if it’s exhibiting symptoms of aging and has damaged areas by storms, leaks, or other issues.

Replacing an old, damaged, or failing roof can be more cost-effective than paying for regular roof repairs, regardless of whether you expect to stay in your house for several decades or sell shortly.

2. Roof Leaks

Primarily the main reason for repairs or re-roofing is a leaking roof. Most importantly, if you’ve noticed water stains on the ceiling or walls of your home, you may have a leaky roof. It might be challenging to find the source of a roof leak, but a licensed roofing contractor can assist.


If you’re a do-it-yourself type of person, check out this blog on “How to Repair a Leaking Roofing” for tips and tricks.

It’s always best to solve leaks as soon as you see it because even a minor leak can eventually lead to more severe issues, such as:

  • Infestation of mold on the roof and framing
  • Ceilings that have been damaged and insulation that has become wet or destroyed

3. The Amount of Damage to the Roof

The likelihood is that your roof has decayed in appearance and has suffered additional physical damage if you’re debating between a roof repair and a roof replacement. Working with a reputable roofing contractor will assist you in better understanding the degree of any roof damage you may be experiencing, allowing you to make the best decision for your house and financial situation.

Roof damage manifests itself in various ways that vary significantly depending on the roofing material used. Still, they can be divided into two broad categories: cosmetic damage and structural damage.

Aesthetic deterioration:

Roofing material appears aged and worn

On or between the roofing materials, moss, black streaks, or algae growth.

Damage to the structure:

Asphalt or wood shingles with curled or cupped edges

Asphalt shingles with missing granules and bare places

Asphalt, tile, or wood shingles that are cracked or broken

Asphalt, tile, wood, or metal roofing components that have been dented or pierced

Metal shingles or panels that are rusted

4. Geographical Area

Do you live in a country that’s susceptible to hailstorms, hurricanes, or tornadoes? If so, it’s crucial to repair missing shingles – or other roofing materials – immediately following a shower to help prevent future difficulties, such as roof leaks.

Damage from hail and falling debris can impact your roof’s long-term performance, look, and capacity to form a watertight roof deck.

Roof Repair and Replacement Costs

A new roof is, without question, one of the most expensive options available to homeowners when deciding whether to re-roof or repair their home’s roofing system.

A complete roof replacement costs you more money; however, if you have a series of repairs to makeover several years, the total cost of those repairs may exceed the price of a complete roof replacement, in the long run, depending on your circumstances.

In addition to providing estimates to assist you in weighing the possibilities of what might be the most cost-effective solution without endangering the structural integrity of your home, a roofing contractor may also be able to give roof financing options.

While a complete roof replacement may be more expensive upfront, it will save you money in the long term.  The reason is because you will not have to pay for further repairs, which is especially important if your roof has many trouble places. In addition, having a new roof can provide you with peace of mind and increased home value.

The Advantages of a Roof Replacement

1. A new roof looks great and improves the appearance of your home’s exterior


A new roof contributes 40% to the overall curb appeal of your home. Your home’s curb appeal will attract attention, either negatively or positively, depending on its appearance. It will fall into the upbeat category if you find a substitute.

When you replace an old, worn-out roof with a new one, the house will appear to be more recent construction. Not only will the replacement provide you with years of peace of mind, but it will also make your property the most attractive on your street.

2. You will have peace of mind after having your roof replaced

Once you have replaced your roof, you will be able to travel without continually monitoring the weather back home. There will be no damage or leaks when you walk back through the door to meet you. That’s what I call peace of mind!

In addition, if you’ve spent money remodeling your house, a new roof will give you peace of mind.  You won’t have to worry about your possessions or renovations getting damaged.

Disadvantages of a New Roof

1. Roofing Construction is Loud and Noisy

Many people want to stay at home while their roof is getting changed to make sure installation goes smoothly. However, it’s important to keep in mind how noisy it can get inside the house. Each homeowner has their own preference, so you can choose to stay at home or plan a trip.

2. Some Roofers Don’t Clean Up Properly

Most roofers will finish 90% of the work, get the check and move on to the next assignment. How about the last 10%?

The final 10% is the inspection and cleanup after a roofer finishes a job. Nails in the yard, rubbish in your bushes, and flat tires for your family and friends if not cleaned up properly.

So, your house looks like a battlefield. If your roofer does not cover your roof with plastic or a tarp, debris will fall on your holiday decorations and other valuables.

This is why it’s critical to have a professional and licensed roofing contractor do the work.  If you live in the Los Angeles surrounding areas, Energy Roofing is experienced and has great roofing reviews.

3. Purchasing a new roof is not a pleasant experience

A new roof is not the same as a jet ski. You will not be able to play with it or enjoy it in the same way that you would with everything else in which you have invested a significant sum of money.

A roof, on the other hand, is an absolute necessity. When you complete your project, you will have the satisfaction of knowing that your home is safe from the weather and that you have a strong foundation under your feet that will last you for many years to come. Furthermore, as previously said, it increases your home’s curb appeal by 40 percent.

Roof Repair Benefits

  • A new roof can charge you more money than repairing the old one.
  • It costs a lot less to fix a roof than to buy a new one. There are parts of your roof that don’t last as long as the rest of your roof does.
  • Roof repairs can help you get more life out of your roof by making it last longer.
  • Ask your roofer what kind of repairs you can make instead of replacing the whole thing, and then do them. If you don’t need to replace your roof, you can add to its life with a repair. It’s easy.

Disadvantages of Repairing the roof

  • Trying to match exact shingle colors for a roof repair can be challenging.
  • Over time, the sun will start to fade the color of the shingles because it is so bright. Therefore, it can be difficult to match a shingle that is changed. It’s almost impossible to match the colors of your old shingles to the colors of the new shingles. Different shingle colors will make your front yard look bad, and your neighbors will notice, too. Overall your home will look bad in different colors. Or you will have to replace roof shingles that can be a long process.
  • If the repairing of the roof is not done rightly, it can cause more problems and leaks in the ceiling.
  • You need someone who knows how to do roof repair work to get the job done right. It’s very different to do repair work and to put in new things. A person who doesn’t know what they’re doing can do more harm than what’s already there can.

Roof replacement in Los Angeles

Are you from Los Angeles or from the surroundings of Los Angeles and looking for a suitable replacement or repairing company? So, we have the solution to all your problems. You can get the best roof replacement in Los Angeles; check out Energy Roofing for an honest assessment of the condition of your roof.

Energy Roofing is a professional roofing firm with the C-39 license number. They have more than ten years of expertise and hundreds of satisfied customers, so they know roofs inside and out. Furthermore, you will appreciate their reasonable charges.

Do you require tile roofers? Installation of a roof? Whether it’s a simple roof shingle repair or a whole roof replacement, their roofing technicians are up to the task with no trouble at all. With their inexpensive costs and convenient location in the Los Angeles and Inglewood areas, they’re the most outstanding choice in the area.

Furthermore, if you are looking for a Los Angeles roofing contractor or you are from the nearby areas of Los Angeles then Energy roofing can be the best option for you.


Now it is easy for you to choose between both roof repair and roof replacement, after studying detailed information about both of them.  Weigh out the advantages and disadvantages, and contact an expert if you’re still not sure.

Furthermore, if you want any service related to roof repair in Los Angeles, you must go to energy roofing to get the best contractors to solve all your worries related to your roof.